Knicks at Crossroads: Contemplating Thibodeau's Future After Eastern Conference Finals Exit

https://icaro.icaromediagroup.com/system/images/photos/16536414/original/open-uri20250602-55-1p9fqua?1748843101
ICARO Media Group
News
02/06/2025 05h36

### Knicks Face Crucial Offseason Decisions After Eastern Conference Finals Exit

The New York Knicks' journey ended in heartbreak as they were ousted from the Eastern Conference finals, experiencing familiar woes with a six-game defeat to the Indiana Pacers. This marked their first trip to this stage since 2000, a series mired in questions about the direction of the team moving forward. The central dilemma: retain the current squad or initiate significant changes?

Coach Tom Thibodeau's future is a particularly contentious issue. Thus far, dismissing Thibodeau appears the most straightforward potential move, avoiding the complexities of salary cap adjustments or trade negotiations. Sports analyst Sam Quinn has suggested this route, though initial indications suggest the team might retain its coach. Nevertheless, with owner James Dolan, the final decision remains undecided.

Following their elimination with a 125-108 loss in Game 6 against the Pacers, The Athletic cited sources revealing Thibodeau enjoys strong support within the organization. Team president Leon Rose and star player Jalen Brunson, who joined the Knicks in 2022 partly due to Thibodeau's presence, are reportedly in Thibodeau's camp. Brunson affirmed his belief in Thibodeau's leadership when questioned if Thibodeau could elevate the team further.

Thibodeau, who took the helm in 2020, immediately revived the Knicks, ending a seven-year playoff drought and earning the Coach of the Year accolade in 2021. Under his direction, the Knicks have consistently made postseason appearances, advancing past the first round three consecutive seasons and reaching their first Eastern Conference finals in over two decades.

Despite these achievements, Thibodeau faces criticism, particularly regarding his tendency to overuse starters. This season, Mikal Bridges vocalized concerns over the demanding minutes, reflecting a recurring issue in Thibodeau's coaching style. Bridges, who averaged 37 minutes per game, ranking fourth in the league, emphasized the physical toll and suggested better utilization of bench players.

Additionally, Thibodeau's hesitation to adjust player rotations, especially in crucial playoff moments, has drawn scrutiny. The main lineup featuring Brunson, Bridges, OG Anunoby, Josh Hart, and Karl-Anthony Towns struggled with a negative net rating, yet changes came late, only during Game 3 of the East finals — by which time the Knicks trailed 2-0 in the series.

Though Thibodeau, who is under contract until 2028 after signing a three-year extension in 2024, has undeniably improved the Knicks' stature in the East, his ability to further elevate the team remains a point of debate. This offseason, the Knicks must carefully consider their next steps, weighing Thibodeau's proven capabilities against the need for potential strategic changes.

The views expressed in this article do not reflect the opinion of ICARO, or any of its affiliates.

Related