The hiatus is over! The MLS Cup Playoffs kick back into gear this Saturday with the second round poised to captivate viewers despite some early shake-ups. Notable exits include Lionel Messi's Inter Miami and Columbus Crew, the defending champions, bowing out unexpectedly in the opening round.

The essence of potential upsets is a crucial component that either makes or breaks the neutral thrill of the postseason. The ongoing format, initiating best-of-three series since 2023, has attracted criticism, especially after the elimination of Miami. The top-seeded Miami, alongside the Crew and FC Cincinnati, failed to advance past the first round, underscoring the unpredictability of the knockout setup.

While the element of surprise contributes to the entertainment value, the format's flaw lies in rewarding regular season excellence. The current format challenges teams to play against each other multiple times in a short span, deviating from the typical one-off encounters in soccer. Atlanta's successful upset over Miami highlighted a strategic approach that exploited the home-field advantage effectively, bringing the series to a thrilling conclusion.

Leading figures, including player Riqui Puig and goalkeeper Stefan Frei, have voiced discontent with the current format. The debate primarily revolves around the utilization of penalty shootouts to settle tied matches, raising questions about the fairness of such outcomes. Teams like Seattle and Minnesota advanced without clinching a win, prompting a reevaluation of the playoff structure.

Critics have suggested a shift towards a group stage setup, a format synonymous with the fervor of the World Cup. Proponents advocate for a tiered draw approach that adds an element of unpredictability, enhancing the competitive spirit among participants. A potential shift towards this format could inject new life into the MLS postseason, resonating with fans and players alike.

As discussions continue regarding the future of the MLS Cup Playoffs, the focus remains on balancing competitive integrity with entertainment value. The push for reform underscores a collective desire to refine the current structure, ensuring a fair and engaging spectacle for all stakeholders involved.

Stay tuned as the MLS navigates through this pivotal juncture, striving to deliver a playoff format that resonates with the dynamic landscape of soccer in North America and beyond.